WAYNESVILLE, N.C. (828NewsNow) — Jurors in Haywood County Superior Court rejected a Waynesville man’s self-defense claim during a Nov. 18 trial in the 2024 death of 45-year-old Jason Caldwell, according to North Carolina District Attorney Ashley Hornsby.

Hornsby made the announcement in a Nov. 18 social media post. She said Thomas Dillard Hooper, 23, was found guilty of first-degree murder and was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole by Superior Court Judge Gary Gavenus.

According to court records, the incident happened on May 13, 2024, at Caldwell’s residence on Allens Creek Road. Hornsby said at the time, Hooper was living with Caldwell and his longtime partner in their house. Hooper was dating Caldwell’s daughter.

Hooper purchased the handgun used to kill Caldwell just hours before the shooting, according to Assistant District Attorney Maryam Hadden. Hadden said Hooper visited two pawn shops and bought a .22-caliber North American Arms Magnum revolver at the second one.

Court records states that Hooper tucked the small revolver in one pocket, and in another pocket, he carried a .22-caliber revolver that fires .22 long ammunition. Officers also found other firearms in his vehicle.

The shooting occurred after Hooper stepped into the hallway of Caldwell’s house and told Caldwell to “shut the fxxk up,” court records showed.

According to testimony, Caldwell started down the hallway toward Hooper, who fired three times. One bullet hit Caldwell in the left shoulder, and the other two bullets penetrated his back, severing his spinal cord, the arrest record showed.

Hornsby said that Hooper testified that he felt threatened because of previous confrontations with Caldwell. Hooper said he fired a total of three shots after Caldwell lunged at him. But prosecutors noted the location of the bullets and the pathologist’s findings of instant paralysis.

“He fired, cocked the gun; fired, cocked the gun; fired, cocked the gun,” Hadden said.

Hadden then told jurors that if Caldwell’s death was justified, then “everyone has an unlimited right to kill.”

“This wasn’t self-defense. It was an execution,” Hadden said.

Hadden also pointed out that the revolver used was a single shot, meaning Hooper had to manually jerk back the hammer before pulling the trigger. Hadden and her co-prosecutor, Michael McEnery, argued that Hooper was angry with Caldwell and had prepared to shoot him when an opportunity presented itself.

Hornsby said that after the arrest, officers allowed Hooper to search the internet to secure a lawyer. They discovered that he also researched laws governing self-defense and stand your ground.

North Carolina’s stand-your-ground law allows individuals to use defensive force – including deadly force – under specific legal conditions. Prosecutors said that you cannot, however, use stand your ground against the lawful owner of the house.

Detective Eric Batchelor of the Waynesville Police Department was the primary detective on the case.